Return to Scribe Page

Class Notes

USMA 1958

  May 2018

Classmates and wives—

 We should have all returned from the 60th Reunion, even those taking a major detour.  Sadly, we have lost two classmates and a wife since the reunion.

 Crosbie E Saint, better known to us as Butch, died on 7 May 2018.  Our prayers are with his widow, Merrilyn.  She is hosting an open house in honor of Butch at their farm on Sunday 3 June.  The address is Hidden Fox Farm, 36036 Jeb Stuart Road, Philomont VA.

 Butch was one of our two Army four stars, the other being Bill Tuttle.  We had one in the Air Force, Mike Dugan, and as you all recall, two in the Royal Thai Army, Sam Sookmark and Pete Kullavanijaya.  Your Scribe was in tall cotton for the class photo at 60th, sitting between two four stars: Bill Tuttle and Sam Sookmark.

 Potential SPAM included here because it pertains to Butch.  There is email going around with the return address blackhorse6@aol.com  This is bogus!  Butch’s email we are warned by Tony Smith was blkhorse6@aol.com  Please note the difference is in spelling of blackhorse (SPAM) versus abbreviated blkhorse (the real deal).

 Next, Sue Oelke was the wife we lost since 60th Reunion.  She died on 22 May.  Sue and Karl were married on graduation day, 4 June 1958.  They produced our class godson, Karl E Oelke III in December 2018.  Our prayers are with both Karl “the elder” and Karl “the younger” in this difficult time.  I am especially sympathetic to class godson Karl because I am the class godson of USMA 36.

Terry Connell added about Sue: “Afraid we'll see many more.  Sue was a sweetheart.  They were good friends with Vantures.  Sorry the 'sharing time' at the reunion was all too short for most everyone -- but the reunion was fabulous...”  Yes, it was fabulous.  Pop your chest way up Garry Roosma.  For the record, I classmated Garry into doing the 30th and he has done all the five-year reunions since then.

And our third loss was Don Palladino who died days ago (27 May).  Don will be buried at West Point, joining Marty who died on 25 March 2009)

 I am having trouble typing this.  It keeps erasing itself.  Wish I knew what I am doing wrong.  I need Pete Trainor.  My intent is to finish before we have any more deaths!

 Now to try importing some more cheerful information from emails stored for these Class Notes since the last edition before the 60th Reunion.  PLEASE NOTE THE SOCIAL EVENT IN DC AREA AT THE END OF THESE NOTES.

 The first cheerful note is from Jack Downing: “I have returned from West Point where I presented the Ramsden Award in Chemistry.  I also spoke with Mr. David Reel, Executive Director of the USMA Museum about our Time Capsule and the possibility that some of the items may be offered to the museum in 2058 when it is opened (or after another 50 years if it is reburied).  He has started a file on it and I hope that the PEB will remind the then-director of it at that time.  As an aside, he showed me the situation map used by Gen Pershing in WWI.  It is quite large and detailed and was rolled up by Gen Pershing and presented to USMA.  (It’s on the second floor just outside his museum office).  From interacting with several cadets, my evaluation of them is the highest.”

 Continuing with cheerful info, the next is from George Lawton: “Classmates, we have a vacancy on the Perpetual Endowment Fund (PEF) Board.  IAW the Article IV Section 2 of the PEF By-Laws, I am nominating Frank Harlem to fill that position and request your vote for him.  Frank had a very successful 26-year career with Caldwell Banker Commercial selling and leasing land to shopping center developers, leasing to-be-built space to users, and selling the finished retail product to institutional and individual investors. He ended his career with them as a senior VP.  Frank is a serious investor in the stock market and a well-versed contributor on the Stockpickers, our email net for classmates who are interested in keeping up with the market.  I believe he will be a great asset to the PEFB and highly recommend him.  He has read our By-Laws and has agreed to sign the required statement that he will abide by them and support the intention of the fund, if voted on the board.  Please send me your vote NLT 30 May 2018.”

 Hugh Trumbull again presented the Capelle Award on behalf of the class at the USMAPS ceremony on 18 May.  Hugh’s report follows: “Well drilled, with well shined brass glinting in a hazy sun, the Prep School Candidates for the West Point Class of 2022 marched in their Final Review.  205 of the 240 who had entered in the Fall showed that they were ready to move on to become Cadets.  This is a very impressive, very diverse group of young Americans.  The Preparatory School continues to fulfill its mission!

 “Selected to receive “The Capelle” this year, was Cadet Candidate Holden S. Quinn from Anchorage Alaska.  CC Quinn is a scholar athlete who has already decided on Infantry and Special Forces.  He is motivated!  We had a chance to chat with Holden and his mother.  We learned that his mother’s father was a Naval officer on the deck when McArthur signed the Japanese surrender.  But, she says she is all Army now and ready to support her son in four years of beating Navy.

 “In the context of the Award, I was able to give a short speech covering Gerry Capelle’s Prep School background, his death in combat and the history and future of the Capelle Trophy.  Alpha Company enjoyed their Pizza Party on the Tuesday evening prior to their graduation, organized by their Company TAC, CPT(P) Chris Mattos.  Interestingly, MAJ Rob Newbill, Deputy Commandant, was a Cadet Candidate at Ft. Belvoir in 1972 when the Capelle Trophy was established, so we had a lot of history to discuss.  MAJ Newbill will be the POC for the Trophy going forward in the transition year.  These fine young men and women passing through the Prep School, some of which have had time in combat, continue to impress us year after year.  They will do well as young leaders and they appear to have the “right stuff” to give our country what it needs in the future.”

 cid:image001.jpg@01D3F50D.43D970E0

 Awards announced

 cid:image002.jpg@01D3F50D.43D970E0

CC Holden S. Quinn in formation as Awards are announced

 cid:image003.jpg@01D3F50D.43D970E0

 Capelle Trophy presented

 Andy Andreson added via an email to Hugh, repeated here for everyone’s benefit: “Thanks so much for representing the Class at the Capelle award event.  And congratulations to Cadet Candidate Quinn!”

 There has been a great deal of email traffic on the Supe’s remarks at the 60th.  Much of it focused on his slide which reflected some 15 generals in 1958 – those on the slide were the fifteen signed up to attend the reunion.  Sadly, Butch Saint did not make it to 60th.  This partial list of generals has caused a great deal of confusion and myriad emails with additional names of generals as classmates remembered them.  To make it easier for all, as well as a reminder for all, I will list our general officers in alfa order with their cadet company indicated.  I will also include the date of death for the 13 who have died:

 MG Andy Andreson G1

BG USAF Dick Beyea B1

MG Jack Bradshaw M2

BG Pete Brintnall M2 (died 16 Sep 2017)

MG Bob Bunker D1

BG USAF Chuck Cabell E1

BG Tom Carpenter M2

BG Pat Donovan G2

GEN Mike Dugan USAF I2

MG Bob Durkin F1 (died 14 Nov 2004)

MG USAF Jud Ellis A2 (died 12 Jan 2001)

BG Claude Fernandez F2 (died 24 Mar 2015)

BG Bill Ganey H1 (died 20 Jan 2016)

LTG Dick Graves M1

MG Mike Harvey E1 (died 9 Nov 2013)

BG Pete Hidalgo K1 (died 15 Dec 2008)

MG Linc Jones I1 (died 16 Jan 2013)

BG USAF Bob Kirtley (died 8 May 1994)

GEN Pete Kullavanijaya B2 Royal Thai Army

BG USAF Bob McCann D2

MG Tim McLean F1

BG Don Palladino F2 (died 27 May 2018)

BG Ben Pellegrini F2

BG Bob Pointer G2

BG Jim Ramsden I2 (died 13 Aug 1998)

BG Dick Reynard I1

MG George Robertson H1

MG Will Roosma H2 (died 29 Apr 2011)

GEN Butch Saint I1 (died 7 May 2018)

MG Alan Salisbury L1

MG Tom Sands K1

MG John Sewall F2

BG Tony Smith I1

LTG USAF Leo Smith G1

GEN Sam Sookmark M1 Royal Thai Army

BG John Soper H2

MG Chuck Teeter L1

GEN Bill Tuttle E2

MG USAF Mac Williams E2

 

Thirty-nine total general officers by my count.  There are two from the Royal Thai Army, 8 from the USAF and 29 from the US Army.  Very sadly, 13 of the 39 have transitioned to the ghostly assemblage as indicated by date of death.

 

DC Social Event.  “The social baton has passed from Jack Gordon to me (email from new social guru, Palmer McGrew) for our DC area class functions.  I have asked several folks to assist me in this enterprise.  I am away for several months in the summer, for one thing. I could use some more help, so let me know if you are willing to help.  Our next event is 14 June at the ANCC in Fairfax.  It will be a buffet lunch.  John Schaffer is providing an excellent speaker, Steve Moore, who is well-connected to the administration and promises to be very interesting.

 “The cost per person is $25.  Drinks can be purchased as usual.  I presume that golfers may add a round with their class buddies.  Golfers please contact Andy Andreson.  Please reply to Palmer McGrew if you will attend.  We will need a good idea of how many are coming.  Hope to see you then, Palmer”

 Scribe must launch this one or it will miss the month of May.  I have more, but I will save it for my next installment in June.  Again, I am using the unrestricted senders class list.  CCQs may send this to company-mates who are on the restricted senders list, the one used by Jack Downing for death notifications.  I have no clue who is on the unrestricted list as opposed to the restricted senders list.  I trust the CCQs know who gets this directly from me (unrestricted senders) and to whom they need to forward this message (restricted senders).  When in doubt, check with our death notifier Jack Downing.

 George as in your friendly Scribe