Arvin Gym Design Proposal
This is an edited version of Bob Doughty's 5 March 2004 message to the class. It has been edited to make it "Web" friendly. Clicking on the link will open it in a separate window. You can shift back and forth between the Close the window to return to this document.
5 March 2004
Classmates,
The Design Subcommittee for the entryway to the Arvin Cadet Physical Development Center has finished its deliberations and received a go-ahead from our Class leaders. We are prepared to submit our proposal through USMA’s Museum, Historical, and Memorialization Committee to the Superintendent but want to ensure members of our Class understand and support our proposal.
The design we posted about a year ago has been modified but the overall concept remains the same. The key change is that we could not get the Superintendent to agree to our mounting the plaque showing our Class’s great success in varsity sports. We do have the Superintendent’s support for our general design and, assuming you concur, will now seek his final approval of our detailed design.
Please read the following carefully and provide me any comments or suggestions you have. Pay special attention to the names of our deceased classmates. Are their names correct? Have we forgotten anyone?
Do not be concerned with spacing, margins, or format of the wording, for the plaques will be sized and formatted carefully by an expert engraver and approved by the Design Subcommittee.
To begin, as you enter the Arvin Center through the original doors, you will see two pillars to your direct front with an archway between them. Just behind them are two other pillars with an archway between them. To the right rear is an alcove in which we plan on placing two benches. We have expressed our desire to display additional information about the Class in the alcove and will pursue this when appropriate.
If you want to see an artist’s rendering of the entryway, go to:
Artist's Rendering
Although this rendering is not exactly what I describe below, it is close enough for you to understand what we are proposing.
We have received the Superintendent’s approval to place on the left front pillar a plaque with information about Bob Arvin’s two Silver Stars, on the right front pillar a plaque memorializing our classmates who died in the service of our country, and on the archway connecting the two pillars our Class slogan "Strength and Drive." Above and on the left of the slogan we will mount a bronze USMA crest, and above and on the right of the slogan we will mount a bronze Class of 1965 crest.
On the archway between the two rear pillars we will mount a quote from President Eisenhower extracted from a telegram he sent our Class just prior to the Army – Navy game in November 1964. On the left rear pillar we will mount a plaque displaying the telegram containing that quote, and on the right rear pillar we will mount the Arvin Wrestling plaque that currently is mounted on the left front pillar.
The Eisenhower quote on the rear archway will be: "You will always have what you give today -- the more you give the more you will keep! D.D.E. ’15"
In the floor to the right and left of the four pillars we will place two small (approximately 2 feet x 2 feet), colored Class of 1965 crests.
The three new plaques are:
1) On the left front pillar, we will mount a plaque with information about Bob Arvin’s two Silver Stars. We propose the following wording for this plaque:
-------------------------------------------[top]
*** (Silver Star) *** (Silver Star)
*** ***
September 5, 1967 October 8, 1967
CARL ROBERT (“BOB”) ARVIN
CAPTAIN, INFANTRY
Hue-Phu Bai Republic of Vietnam
On 5 September 1967 then-Lieutenant Bob Arvin was an advisor to the 7th Vietnamese Airborne Battalion when his unit came under intense mortar and small arms fire. Though wounded, Bob disregarded the fierce fire and was leading his element forward to engage the enemy when his radio operator was also wounded. Bob dragged the soldier to safety and, undaunted by the perilous circumstances, returned to direct repeated helicopter gunship strikes. He refused his own medical evacuation until the objective was secure and the mission complete. For his conspicuous gallantry in action and calm courage, he was awarded the Silver Star.
Following hospitalization, Bob requested an immediate return to combat duty. On 8 October 1967 his unit was completing a sweep of a suspected enemy base when it encountered an entrenched enemy regiment. Intense enemy fire pinned down Bob’s battalion in an exposed, untenable position. In full view of the enemy he valiantly moved through the fire to a forward vantage point. There, as fighting raged about him, he directed extremely accurate, close-range gunship passes onto enemy positions. As he continually moved through fire-swept fields to position himself better to direct the supporting fire, Bob was mortally wounded. His unremitting attention to duty and superb direction of ground forces and supporting aircraft had enabled his battalion to defeat a strong and determined enemy three times its size. For his heroic actions, he was awarded his second Silver Star.
Bob Arvin’s indomitable fighting spirit, positive leadership, and resolute courage throughout intense combat reflect great credit upon himself, the U.S. Military Academy, and the U.S. Army.
-------------------------------------------------[bottom] |
2) On the right front pillar, we will mount a plaque that memorializes our classmates who died in the service of our country. PLEASE TAKE THE TIME TO ENSURE WE HAVE NOT FORGOTTEN ANYONE AND HAVE NOT MADE MISTAKES IN THEIR NAMES. We recommend using the informal names by which we knew them rather than the full, formal names listed in Cullum Hall and the Register. About a year ago we asked the Class about using this informal approach and received over-whelming support.
As for the criteria for being on the list, we believe a classmate must have died while in the service for service-related causes. In other words, dying for health-related reasons does not meet the criteria for being on the list. We propose the following wording for this plaque:
------------------------------ [top]
In the service of our country
All gave some, and some gave all.
Our classmates and dear friends who gave all.
Bob Arvin
Mike Berdy
Tony Borrego
Charlie Brown
Jamie Bryan
Jerry Clark
Dick Collins
Doug Davis
Spot De Witt
Chuck Dickey
Dick Endicott
Bob Gagne
Mike Glynne
John Hays
Chuck Hemmingway
Jack Hutton
Marv Jeffcoat
Gary Kadetz
Bob Keats
Bernie Kistler
Ed Menninger
Mike Momcilovich
Chet Myers
Pat O’Toole
Chuck Wuertenberger
Bob Zonne
"Well done! Be thou at peace."
--Class of 1965
---------------------------------------- [bottom] |
3) On the left rear pillar we propose putting a copy of the message President Eisenhower sent on the eve of the 1964 Army-Navy football game. At the bottom of the plaque will be one sentence that explains the significance of the message.
-------------------------------------------- [top]

* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Following Ike’s exhortation, the 1965-led Army Team gave everything in an 11 - 8 upset over Navy.
---------------------------------------- [bottom] |
4) The Arvin Wrestling Plaque is currently mounted on the left front pillar and lists the winners each year of the wrestling award. We intend to move it to the right rear pillar. We are concerned about its color, which has turned darker as it has aged, and may replace the plaque if its color is distinctly different from the other plaques.
If you have comments or suggestions, please send them to me at:
RobertDoughty@hvc.rr.com or Robert.Doughty@usma.edu |