Return to Scribe Page

Class Notes

USMA 1958

  November 2017

Classmates—

Highly disorganized this month.  Have no clue what will show up in Class Notes, but here goes.

 Our Losses.  Sadly, we lost two classmates and another wife since the last Class Notes in October.  Classmates deaths that I do not think have been recorded in our Class Notes begin with Robert L Hultzen K2 who very recently transitioned to the Ghostly Assemblage.  Our prayers are with his wife Lisa.  Bob went Signal Corps at graduation in 1958.  Our paths did not cross in the Army before he resigned in 1961 as a 1LT.  Bob and Lisa lived in California.  His entry in the 50-year book was taken from our 30-year book.  Scribe highly recommends you read it.  Most of this info came via an email from Bo Craddock K2, which I will quote it here: “Just got off the phone with Lisa Hultzen, Bob’s wife for about the last 10 years. Bob died peacefully with what Lisa called an ‘aortic dissection’ on October 9th in a hospital in Las Vegas. His death was sudden. He was cremated and wanted no ceremonies. He had written his own memorial article (which is what motivated Lisa to call me). She will mail it to me and I will submit it. Her address is 6169 North Hwy 66, Kingman, AZ 86401.  Lisa will send me the obit when it is available. Lisa was impressed with how much Bob loved USMA and what it meant to him. His diploma graced the wall of his law office. I plan to pass to Dave Bourland K2 CCQ any future correspondence I receive from Lisa.”

 Dwain T Moentmann C1 followed all too quickly on 10 October.  Most knew him as “Bud.”  His is another good entry in 50-year book.  Scribe loves the paragraph “I will always be indebted to Jim and Peggy Morgan I2 for introducing me to Holly, a young widow with a four-year old daughter, Lane.  We had our first date on the fourth of July 1972 and were married later that year.  I adopted Lane soon after our marriage.”  Lane became a step-sister to Bud’s two children from his first marriage: James (#38665) class 1981, a retired COL, and Jennifer.  And, they have produced in Bud’s words “eight wonderful grandchildren.  Life is good!”  Two of his eight grandchildren are grads: Tommy (#66691, son of James) Class of 2010 and Grant Petersen (#71044, son of Jennifer, I think) Class of 2014.  Our prayers are with Holly, their children and grandchildren.  I have always been sympathetic for those who have lost a soul-mate, but it became far more personal with my loss of Judy year ago.

 The wife who left us earlier this year was Ann Henninger, wife of Corky E2.  Ann died on 17 Feb 2017.  The Henningers were among the first of 1958 to marry on 5 June – the day after graduation!  Sorry about the late notification of Ann’s death, but Scribe just received the email forwarded by Chuck Toftoy E2 CCQ.  This explains why she was not mentioned in earlier Class Notes.  Ann and Corky produced a son Kermit who graduated from USMA in 1981 (#38461).  Corky’s entry in the 50-year book is an edited version from our 30-year book.  They spent 7-plus years at West Point, which culminated with his working for then-LTG Goodpaster while the latter was Supe “during times of great change…”

 Now to more cheerful news.  I was then-MG Goodpaster’s aide (1961-62) some years before he became Supe while he commanded the 8th Infantry Division in Germany.  The division had an Airborne Brigade which caused General Goodpaster to go through airborne training.  A memorable event for me was completing five jumps in one day at Finthen Army Airfield when Gen Goodpaster became Airborne qualified.  Garry Roosma H2 was our Otter pilot.  In my memory it was only “the day before yesterday.”  Five jumps in one great day!

Football.  A recent email on the forum from Tony Smith I1 had these football stats which are repeated here because (1) not all are on the Class Forum, (2) they are great stats and (3) I needed something to brighten up these notes.  Tony wrote: “Army received votes in both the AP Top 25 and the Coaches Polls; Navy got none.  Want to know why Army football is doing so well? The stats tell the story.

“Individual:  Ahmad Bradshaw is #10 in the nation in rushing yards at 1132.  Navy's Zach Abey is #8 at 1202.  Team (there are 129 teams in FBS football):

·         Rushing Yards:  Army #1 with 365.4/game; Navy #2 with 346.1; AF #6 at 324.8.  (Air Force had been #2 until Army held them to 95 yards rushing Saturday!)

·         Fumbles Lost:  Army is #6 in fewest fumbles lost - 2 (that's huge!)  (Navy not in top 25 in this)

·         Penalties:  Army is #8 in fewest penalties at 4.11/game; Navy is #14 at 4.38.  Army ranks #5 in least amount of yardage lost to penalties

·         Time of Possession:  Army ranks #4; Navy is #2

·         3rd Down Conversions:  Army is #2 with 59 out of 115 tries; Navy is #7 with 55 of 113.

·         4th Down Conversions:  Army is #16 with 14 of 21 tries; Navy is #26 with 10 of 16

·         Tackles for Loss Allowed:  Army is #3 at 3.22/game; Navy is #17 with 4.38

“And here's my favorite!  Sacks Allowed:  Army leads the nation with fewest sacks allowed - a grand total of 1 in 9 games this season!  (If you never throw a pass, you can truly eliminate the sacks.)  Navy is #14 in this stat.  Seriously, the stats tell a story.  Army is playing disciplined football (few penalties) and minimizing miscues (fumbles lost, tackles for loss)).  If you don't beat yourself, you can beat your opponents.

“Go Army, beat Duke and Navy!”  Hal Lyon C2 replied to Tony’s email “Tony, good report.  And, Scribe can endorse both of Tony’s final thoughts re beating Duke and Navy and support Hal’s reply.

Class Stats.  Recently your Scribe sent an email to the class with stats on our losses/deaths.  They are repeated here in case you missed them and info is always required to fill up these notes:

 - 228 graduated classmates

- 9 who graduated in 1959

- one who graduated in 1960 (Tom Taylor, our last graduate from the class)

- one honorary classmate (Chaplain George Bean)

- 26 former cadets (did not graduate – these are difficult to track – there are probably more)

- 93 wives

 The stats have prompted a few replies already.  Butch Saint I1 asked for the positive number: how many of us are alive from those who graduated in June 1958?  The math is 573 grads minus 228 deaths.  And, the answer is 345.  Sadly, not all of us are doing well in the health department, therefore, stay in touch with your company CCQ and with one another.  Chuck Davis G1 wrote “Thanks for those stats, George.  Much appreciated, even if the subject is one we all tend to push down the line of time.  Man does, indeed, not know his time.”  I will repeat Chuck’s final thought: “Man does, indeed, not know his time.”  Andy Andreson G1 commented “Thanks, George, for the information.  Pete Trainor’s ‘Taps’ list at the website has both grads and some non-grads, but I was unaware until now how may classmates we have lost.”   Rich Gell C1 replied with a stat from Wikipedia which saysthe latest life expectancy figure for the US male is 76.9, from 2015 WHO DATA.  Looks like we are doing pretty well!”  Rich then sent a follow-up message “P.S.  A different website shows 79.1 for white males and also shows data for each state.  FWIW.”  Scribe likes the upgrade in life expectancy.  Also, thinks the ending abbreviation FWIW means “for what it’s worth.”  There are many different numbers for life expectancy, but those of us still standing seem to out-lasting them all.  This is one stat to keep beating!

 Six-year Men.  Scribe has written this before, but it bears repeating.  We have three six-year men in our class.  I say again THREE.  First, Bud Davenport E2 began his cadet career with 1956 and graduated with us on 4 June 1958.  Next, Tom Fletcher F2, who died on 22 Sep 1998, began with 1957, joined us and then was graduated with 1959.  Our third in this category was Tom Taylor D1 who began with us, joined 1959 and was graduated in 1960.  Tom Taylor died 1 Oct 2017, which was reported last month in the October Class Notes.  Bud Davenport is still with us!  He and I were Army brats together at Ft Leavenworth in 1947-48.  He was my hero -- a high school freshman football player in the town of Leavenworth while I was in the 6th grade.  Pretty sure we lived in the same apartment building.  And, Bud is still a hero with whom I crossed paths only a few times during our service years.  Bud’s is another great write-up in the 50th year-book.  Scribe loves the photo of Bud and his FAC aircraft in SEA.  I hope to see Bud & Ginger at the 60th.

 60th Reunion.  An exchange of emails between Bill Serchak CCQ K1 and George Lawton CCQ G2 provided info about Josh & Noni Jaschen K1.  The Lawtons had visited the Jaschens in Naples, Florida.  The latter are preparing to move to a CCRC (continuing care retirement community).  Scribe applauds the move.  We Siberts made a similar move in August 2008 to Goodwin House Alexandria, a CCRC here in Northern Virginia.  No yard, meals provided, plenty of neighbors, smaller “house” (Judy and I moved to a two-bedroom apartment with space for most of our furniture).  The sad news provided in Lawton’s email was that the Jaschens are not planning on attending the 60th Reunion.  Among other reasons, too far to travel.  Not included in the emails, but reported earlier is that son Daryl (class of 1982 who resigned in 1990, I think) was selected for BG in VA Army National Guard in 2014.  Another I think fits here.  Unfortunately, I cannot find my old notes, so I hope this information about son Daryl is accurate.  Enough of my lousy memory and back to emails between Serchak and Lawton.  Mary Jane and George expect to see Noni and Josh again after Christmas when the Lawtons return to Florida.

Free Beer Again at 60th!  Here is another reason to attend the 60th Reunion – Chuck Toftoy E2 has done it again!  Here is his email: “All: I’m really happy because we are getting free beer again, for our 60th from the Boston Brewery.  Samuel Adams for Benny Havens Tavern. 🍺  Please respond to me, casb@gwu.edu, as to whether you want regular(reg) or light(lgt).  Do not reply to this email address (the Class one) because it will not count.  You only need to send me one abbreviation, ie ‘reg’ or ‘lgt’. That keeps it simple.  Thanks.  Again send your choice to me only at casb@gwu.edu.  Thanks.  Hang in there.  Chuck, E2 CCQ Beat Navy! 🏈”.

Plebe BoxingWally Ward M1 replied to an email from Jack Downing H2 about this topic.  Scribe quotes: “Palone was teaching us a boxing lesson.  He had us lined up in straight line & requested each one to try & hit him.  All failed & then it was my turn.  I hit him with full face hit & he counter-punched me with a strong right to the jaw after I let my arms down at my side.  He immediately hugged me to let me know he had made a mistake in hitting me.  He did know that I was the runner-up champion in the First Army the year before I came to West Point.  You may want to pass this on to our classmates.”  At age 17 your Scribe was lousy in Plebe boxing.  I am surprised that I am including this information, but Wally was most recently our leader in the Plebe March Back and looks like he can still box!

TOF’s TIPS #86 is quoted here: “As we get older, we lose our sense of taste and we lack our appetite.  Even our sense of smell diminishes.  Some people only take small bites even if it's their favorite food.  Patty's Mom ate 2 or 3 bites of food at the Assisted Living facility or when we took her out to a restaurant.  She became frail and loss a lot of weight.  It was hard to watch her deteriorate. 

 “Some of the reasons for this problem are: ulcers, dementia, thyroid disease, depression, ill-fitting dentures (causing difficulty in chewing).  Swallowing can be a problem too.  All of these issues impair a sense of hunger.  Another consideration is that chemotherapy kills off most of the taste buds.  And a person may have a touchy digestive system.

 “Basically, you or whoever it is, needs a medical evaluation to ascertain what is causing the loss of interest in food.  Also, your Doc needs to determine whether supplements you take interfere with your meds.  If you are trying to get someone to buck up their eating ability, here are my suggestions:

- Go for a high-fat, high calories diet.  This is based on my research.  For the general population, a low-fat, low-calorie diet is recommended.  But for seniors, becoming frail and/or losing weight...go for higher fat and calories. 

- Eggs (7 grams protein per egg), peanut butter (2 tbls = 8 grams protein), cheese, fruits, dried fruits, nuts, raw veggies, hummus I love it), edamame, ice cream (an expert Doc recommends a bowl of ice cream).  Make sure it is the person's favorite (mine is butter pecan). 

- Make healthy smoothies.  Add nut butter, avocado slice, some spinach and wheat germ (a winner).

- Add lots of color to meals.  Important.  Make it look super.  But very small portions, otherwise it is intimidating to the person which could be you.  Eat the same meal right with the person. This is my brainstorm. Important.  Smaller meals, more often is helpful.  Gradually make changes. 

- Try Boost or Ensure.  These drinks are not a substitute for a meal and are not a complete source of nutrition.  But, they do provide vitamins and minerals.  I suggest Boost (I like the Chocolate Sensation with 15g of protein-Yes!).  I take it daily with my vitamins.  The vits seem to go down easier. 

- Pump in protein and calcium...however you can do it.  That person (maybe you) - will suddenly buck up.  Don't forget protein is the main building block of our body.  Needs: Men = 56g daily; women = 46g. DRI (Dietary Nutrition Intake) calls for 0.36g per pound of weight.  More protein is needed if active,

- Exercise.  If you have joint pains or using a power chair or wheelchair, water aerobics is best. Docs agree with this 100%.

“Hang in there, Chuck E2 CCQ

 Scribe is on a roll.  Here is TOF’s TIPS #85.  “Pacemakers treat fatigue, light headedness, dizziness, and fainting.  You might want one if you have an abnormal heart beat, congestive heart disease, or afib.  It takes about 3 hours to insert a pacemaker.  I have one and can't even remember the surgery...it was so simple.  Outpatient.  It's great because, in my case, my heart rate is not allowed to go below 70 beats/minute. If it does, the pacemaker kicks in.

 “The pacemaker is composed of a small titanium encased pulse generator that contains a lithium battery.  Batteries last from 5-15 years depending on how active the pacemaker is.  Average battery life is 7-8 years.  It only takes 1-2 hours to change the generator battery.  Usually the original leads (connected to the heart) do not have to be replaced.

 “You can exercise with no difficulty---walking, running, cycling, swimming. I still compete in the Senior Olympics. Nobody knows I have a pacemaker and I never even think about it.

 “If you have a pacemaker and want to know symptoms of your pacemaker failure, here they are: dizziness, fainting, palpitations, shortness of breath, twitching of muscles in chest.  Mine has never failed and I don't know of anyone who has had it fail.  Keep in pace with the rest of us by getting a pacemaker (if you need it).  Talk to your Doc.  Hang in there. Chuck E2 CCQ

 Scribe is still on a roll.  TOF’s TIPS #84 re SLEEP – How much is enough?  “This tip and the last three, were topics suggested by several of you.  I'm always open for topics.

 “Bottom line -- for adults 65+ you need 7-8 hours of sleep per night.  The National Sleep Foundation states that 35% of all adults get less than 7 hours. Their study showed an average of 6 hrs, 45 mins during the week.

 “UNHEALTHY BEHAVIOR CAN OCCUR DUE TO HAVING JUST A LITTLE SLEEP.   Examples are mood swings, grogginess, and weight gain.

 “Take a test---by going to bed at the same time...do not set alarm clock.  See how many hours you sleep.  Try this for several days.  After this test, you can determine your sleep cycle. 

 “If you are sleep deprived, a nap can be awesome to improve your mood, alertness, memory retention, and overall performance.  A NASA study reveals that a 40 minute nap increases alertness by 100%.  They try this with astronauts.  Even a 6-minute nap can improve your memory retention.

 “I've never napped but ardent nappers were JFK, Churchill, Edison, and Napoleon.  (Your Scribe is a napper!)

 “An optimal nap according to experts is 90 minutes, taken between 1-3pm. For ways to get to sleep and sleep soundly see TIP# 79.  (per Scribe, #79 is not included here)

 “One additional suggestion is to not have caffeine or other sleep disruptive meds 6 hours before bedtime.  Check with your Doc... some meds should be taken in the morning because a side effect could be sleep disturbance.

 “All of this info I've provided is fine...but frankly, just make sure you get a minimum of 6 hours of sleep/night.  Hang in there, Chuck E2 CCQ

Memorial Service.  Jim Tilley D2 reported on the memorial service for Joe Keyes D2 at West Point.  “The memorial service was as perfect as is possible to be.  Cloudless sky and bright sun.  The process began with a mass at the Catholic chapel which was personal and inspiring finishing with everyone singing the third verse of the Alma Mater.  Very emotional.  Next was the ceremony at the cemetery which was, as usual, executed to perfection.  As the actual internment was completed, a single Monarch butterfly flew over the urn.  It literally took everyone’s breath away.  The group eventually assembled at the West Point Club for lunch.  Joe’s daughter Jennifer had orchestrated the entire weekend with dinners, a tour of the Academy, a cruise on the Hudson and myriad other activities.  They had decided that Joe would have wanted happiness and celebration not sadness.

 And more from Paul Ruud D2 CCQ.  Paul provided the info from Jim Tilley and had this ending: “The family and class were represented by Jan Keyes and their daughter Jennifer, Bob McCann D2, Bill Gillette/Nancy D2, Ed Ofgant/Marisa D2, Gary Roosma/Jill H2 and Sally Kurtz and me (Jim Tilley).

Prostate Cancer and the roles within 1958 on this subject for John Brinson C2 and Stan Bacon I2 from an exchange of emails between them and shared with class forum.  Stan: “To view the latest updated PC Diagnosis Distribution Table posted for us by Dale Cockle I2 on our PC Support website, go to <http://www.west-point.org/class/usma1958-pc/>.

 “It shows the distribution over time of our 87 known diagnoses. While we remain below the national average and new cases have steadily declined since the latest peak in 2006, we continue to be assaulted—one more diagnosis so far this year, and the threat persists.

 “That 87 total may be understated. We thought we had a fair handle on the number, but we continue to be surprised with ones we hadn't known about.  Your help in our keeping stats accurate and our providing support where requested will be greatly appreciated and treated confidentially.

 “The Class PC Support Group places emphasis on prevention up front and support after the fact in working through one's diagnosis, treatment selection and post treatment issues—all dealt with in confidence.  Let's be really careful out there.”

 John: “Great job. You have led the way for other Classes as well. All of us owe you a bunch of gratitude for helping so many West Pointers deal with prostate cancer.”

Stan: “Thanks for the kind words, John. But recall it was you who took me by the hand and taught me the difference between a DRE and a PSAT and what all the group needed in the way of support. ‘We who rise to new heights stand on the shoulders of giants.’”

John: “Thanks, but truth be known, you get all the credit for this great project, a project that has helped so many West Pointers deal with prostate cancer.”

Scribe: AMEN, AMEN, AMEN!  And, thanks to you both for information on prostate cancer, its prevention and cure.

 More on boxing.  “I read this article about boxing at WP in the WSJ but here is an alternative address that may not need a subscription to the paper.  http://tinyurl.com/y7e5q84f  It would make ‘Punchies’ Creighton and Palone proud.”  Provided by Jack Downing H2.

Perpetual Endowment Fund (PEF).  Info via George Lawton G2.  “The PEFB has two members, Gerry Mitchell and Dale Hruby, Jr (USMA 83) who are completing their term of service on the board. IAW Art IV, Sec2(a) of the PEF By Laws, the board is nominating their replacements for your vote and confirmation.  Jack Downing is nominated to fill Jerry Mitchell’s position, and Dan Peck (USMA 83), Jim Peck’s son is nominated to fill Dale Hruby, Jr’s position.  Please submit your vote on these two gentlemen to me NLT 16 Nov 2017 so we can reconstitute the board prior to our upcoming meeting. (Scribe: submit your vote via email to Lawton).

 Alumni Glee Club concert.  This concert will be on 18 November at the Schlesinger Center (just off Beauregard in Alexandria).  Garry & Jill Roosma H2 will be attending with his brother John & Diane Roosma.  John is a former cadet 1952 and retired USAF Colonel.  Our own Alan Salisbury L1 and Palmer McGrew I2 will be singing with the glee club.  Are there any other classmates singing?  Your Scribe will be attending but not singing.  Remember what Mr Mayer said to him during choir tryouts during Beast Barracks in July 1954: “Your grandfather could not sing; your father could not sing; and you cannot sing.  Next.”

 Memorial Articles.  Paul Vanture B2 has the unenviable task of getting Memorial Articles written and published.  He has worked a miracle in that “We now have 47 classmates who have signed up to write living memorial articles.  Many have already sent them to AOG.”  PD is collecting the remainder and will send them to WPAOG.  If you have not written your own, please consider doing so and contacting Paul.  Scribe has begun his own and will send it to Paul in due course.  Far easier for YOU to do your own than for some other classmate to be stuck doing it for you.  And, if you do it, the memorial article will say what you want, how you want to be remembered.

 Mike Harvey.  Brad Johnson K1 and Brad Eliot G2 and some other classmates were exchanging emails about Mike Harvey E1.  Scribe did a little research and came up with the following: Mike Harvey served in 61st Avn Co during his first tour in VN (1963-64), as Troop Cdr in 1st Bn 9th Cav during his second tour (1966-67) and in 7th Bn 17th Cav during his third tour (1971-72).  You can look him up in 2015 Register of Graduates: #22182-1958.  He died 8 Nov 2013 and his memorial article was in 2014 TAPS.

 The Schroeders and Gretes recently got together in Destin FL.  Please see the photo of the four attached.  My grandfather lived in Destin for many years and even has a street named for him there.  He is responsible for the Infantry opening the Rest Camp there while he was a battalion commander at Ft Benning in 1930 or so.  He then retired there after WW2.  Judy and I visited him there often, as did Garry & Jill Roosma during flight school at Ft Rucker AL in 1959 or so. 

 Time to end this effort launch it.